Knowing Me Knowing You
| Title: |
Knowing Me Knowing
You |
| Author: |
Jim Wingate |
|
Publisher: |
English Teaching
Professional/DELTA Publishing |
| Consists of: |
Teachers Resource
Book |
| Summary: |
Understand your
students (and possibly yourself) |
| Reviewed by: |
Mark Limb |
| Review date: |
May 2003 |
|
Knowing Me Knowing You is a series of fully photocopiable
worksheets designed with the laudable aim of assisting students to "improve
communication skills", "enhance fluency", "foster relationships with self and
others", "provide insights" into their preferred ways of "thinking and
learning". and develop "a light-hearted look at their purpose in life"(!!). The
book generally achieves all of these aims (except perhaps for showing us the
meaning of life) and the activities are, on the whole, extremely popular with
students. The author, Jim Wingate, utilises a humanistic approach in this book
and "draws on ideas" from Multiple Intelligences, Neuro-Linguistic Programming
(NLP) and "Pop Psychology". Ultimately, the book sets out to achieve its aims
by encouraging both the student and teacher to understand the way in which each
other thinks and learns. Each activity is accompanied by comprehensive teaching
notes, consisting of an aim, note to the teacher, detailed teaching method and
occasionally useful background/supplementary information and optional follow up
lessons. Knowing Me Knowing You is a part of DELTA Publishing's
"copycats" series of teachers' resource books and as such, with its ring
binding and wide margins, is physically easy to manipulate in a photocopier.
Upon first glance, this book appeared to be a collection of
activities to help the teacher to secretly psychoanalyse their students under
the guise of an English class. However, the book's humanistic foundations
rapidly emerge so that the book changes from being a "find out what makes 'em
tick" kind of book to a "let's discuss and explore together what makes each of
us tick in our own special way" kind of book. I must admit, I've always been
somewhat scared of using this kind of humanistic approach in my classes, so I
was skeptical (and, I'm now sad to admit, even cynical) at first. However the
reactions I received from my students when I first trialed these activities,
served to quickly eradicate my doubts. My students thoroughly enjoyed the
activities I used, particularly the "pop psychology" quizzes. These activities
generated great discussions and true construction of language for the first
time amongst this group of students. The most impressive aspect of this book is
the insight the activities give to the teacher regarding their students'
methods of learning in general. I have certainly gained a far greater
understanding of my students by using this book and this has in turn allowed me
to greatly improve the design of future lessons, with my students' specific
capabilities and learning preferences in the fore-front of my mind. Students
seem to really appreciate this extra effort and I'm sure the exponents of the
humanistic approach would say that the students have also gained a greater
insight into the mind of their teacher through these activities.
There are of course certain limitations to this book. To get the
most from the book you would want to have a small, regular class where you are
able to have close interpersonal contact with the students. It would be almost
impossible to effectively utilise the vast bulk of these activities in a large
class. The book is supposedly designed for teenagers from "early-intermediate
and above" to "high-intermediate and above". When dealing with adult students
these level guides are accurate. However, I discovered that much of the
quasi-colloquial language used in this book was extremely difficult for
middle-intermediate teenagers to comprehend.
Although I'm certainly not a "humanistic convert" after using
this book, my mind has been opened to the possibilities of such an approach.
With time, I'm certain that both my teaching abilities and my students'
communicative skills will be greatly improved in the classes in which I use
this book. I'm also sure I'll be able to use this book repeatedly in the
future. If you have a small class of intermediate or above adult students or
advanced teenage students whom you see frequently, then I really cannot
recommend Knowing Me Knowing You enough. Being able to deliver a lesson
directly to an individual student's preferred method of learning is obviously
extremely useful, and Knowing Me Knowing You gives you the tools to do
just that. Mark Limb is an English teacher with
obviously far too much spare time on his hands. |