Archive for the ‘TEFL blacklist’ Category

Hi Bruce, welcome back to TEFLtastic. It’s a shame we never get anyone from TEFL International contributing to TEFL.net when it isn’t connected to teacher training. Let me know if any of your trainers are interested in writing book reviews or articles for us.

I am certain that can be arranged!

For Part Three, I’d like to do an update on what has changed in TEFL International and in the TEFL world more generally since your last comment in Interview Part Two on 28 July this year. I haven’t been following all the various stories very closely, so apologies if you have to repeat some things you’ve said many times elsewhere but I guess most people reading are in the same situation as me. I’ll ask for your comments on things I’ve heard, and then give you a chance to mention other things. 

OK

There are some reports of trouble with the immigration police connected to a TEFL International course in China- any information or comments?

I heard it all second hand but this is what I know.  In April 2008 the visa laws in China changed leading up to the Olympics.  Some people got caught in the cracks, the Course Administrator really failed (failed might be too strong of a term as it was a difficult if not impossible situation) and the police closed down the school.

I was unhappy with the way the CA handled things and I relieved him of his duties.  I immediately resolved the situation and we began offering legal courses the following month.

I have publicly posted on several websites about this situation and asked that if anyone feels they were cheated in some way that they should contact me directly or contact the BBB.

Can’t you just contact the course participants directly through their contact details and offer everyone a refund or whatever?

The accusation was not about one specific course.  It was a general accusation about our course in Beijing and even our organization in general.  Therefore we made a general offer to any participants that feel they have been cheated.

Has this made you make changes to how you recruit Course Administrators so that you get someone you don’t have to fire next time?

Unfortunately, no.  The CA was a grad and we thought he was good and professional.  Hiring is not, nor has it ever been, an exact science.

In the comments of Interview Part Two I also gave a link to someone saying that they’d paid for a course under another name in Argentina (“My program (GIC Argentina) sends its TEFL students to the TEFL International classes, but they never told me that or where to go or when”) and then were surprised (but remarkably unperturbed) when they got moved over to a TEFL International course. 

I actually have no idea.  Perhaps a local course that was unable to run with one or two trainees decided to send them over to us?

So you give individual centres a lot of freedom to decide this kind of stuff without contacting TEFL International central?

Not really.  I am a bit baffled about this “complaint”.  I would guess that this person jus became confused after looking at 10 different sites with 10 slightly different claims and became confused.  That happens a lot.

Do you not think most of the genuine complaints there have been come down to this?

No.  There have been a few instances when a trainer just does not do his/her job well or circumstances beyond our control cause a problem.

Do you think that would be acceptable if it happened?

Every case is different.  Whenever we have a complaint we deal with every person differently, depending upon how they want to proceed.

Are there any other genuine and bogus complaints since you last commented here that you’d like to mention or explain how you responded?

The only major event in the last year plus has been July Beijing.  Everything has been rather smooth.  A minor hiccup with British Council but that seems to have been resolved.

Can you/ would you like to give details on the British Council thing?

[No answer given]

I’ve also seen your own comments on Ajarn about court cases you’ve been involved in. Can you give us a brief update here?

Not a lot more has happened since my ajarn.com update.  The court cases are going very well from our side and I believe they will completely vindicate me and all the crazy accusations that were made on TEFLWatch and several other sites that used TW as a source.  It will never make all the attacks worthwhile, but there will at least be some justice.

I can’t find the original thread. Can you summarize it here?

Dumb guy who cheated me is thoroughly exposed in court.  He was one of the main posters on ajarn.com attacking me and now he has been exposed as a liar and a thief.  More charges still pending and more people will go to jail in the end.

This is not a fun situation for me.  Far from it.  But after I was blatantly cheated and then publicly humiliated with lies on TW by these guys, I cannot say I am not looking forward to getting a bit of justice.

In a Stickman interview (http://www.stickmanweekly.com/StickMarkII/BruceVeldhuisenLordOfTEFL.htm) you really lay into the people who post on Ajarn, so why would you start your own thread on it?

I posted it on the 2 main sites frequented by expats in Thailand.  One of those sites is ajarn.com.  TW was always predominantly Thai-based and ajarn.com is certainly one of the best ways to contact the Thailand teaching community.

I also read someone suggesting that Dave Hopkins has moved on from TEFL International. If that is true it must be a blow, as your comments seemed to suggest you relied on him a lot to maintain academic standards since you stopped using IATQUO.

Dave is still very much a full-time employee of TEFL International.  I appreciate his skills, dedication and efforts very much.  But he is going to retire eventually. 

Any idea how the rumour started?

LOL you must be joking.  In the two years under which I have been under attack, the rumours have either been a very serious twist of the truth or simply a complete fabrication.  There are people who will simply MAKE THINGS UP out of thin air.  And some of these people owned and controlled rather prominent websites.  I could give you dozens and dozens of examples.

Well, Dave WILL retire eventually I have no doubt.  Just a guess but I would think Dave has worked longer for me than for any other employer.  He now works PT at Asian University but he has an agreement with me to work at least through June of 2009.

The site ESL Judge, that you supported the setting up of and was supposed to offer a fairer arbitration process than blogs such as this seems to have disappeared. Any idea what happened?

None.  It’s too bad.  A worthwhile site that tried to assist people in resolving disputes.  I am tempted to try to get it reopened.

Sandy MacManus’s most recent blog has also bitten the dust (with the person who was blackmailing him with revealing his true identity trying to make him think the attacks came from you, amongst others). A cause for joy amongst TEFL course providers such as yourself, or do you think TEFL blacklisters do have a role to play?

I think bloggers have to be fair.  Sandy was not.  One prime example was when someone made a comment he interpreted to be a physical threat.  He immediately accused me and spent quite a bit of time calling me every name in the book.  When it turned out to be just an inside joke from his friend, he never retracted a thing he said or bothered to apologize.  People with that mentality, with such an inability to treat people fairly, should not have blogs. 

I see your point of course, but journalists get paid to do lots of research and have legal departments and editors to make sure they remain fair. If you haven’t got some kind of passion driving you such as a chip on your shoulder, why would you bother running such a site for no pay? The way I see it, if Sandy doesn’t do it no one will. (My own motivation for blogging is a vague hope that people will offer me paid ELT writing work, but TEFL blacklisting bores me so I don’t bother even though I think it could be a worthy cause if done properly).

So what you are saying is its ok to do a half-assed job.  It’s only the internet and we do this for free.  Sorry, that just doesn’t cut it.  The reality is that sandy has the potential to be read by millions of people.  If he is not going to do a professional job of it he should keep his opinions to himself.

Alex, remember that when you have a site like sandy’s you are potentially damaging the livelihood of hundreds of people.  He has certainly damaged my reputation.  And with what information?  Absolute lies copied from TW.  Lies easily proven to be lies.  Did he bother to spend 2 minutes emailing me for my side of the story?  Nope.

I believe in Karma.

Thanks Bruce.

Comments and questions from others welcome, but under the usual rules:

- One comment or question per post

- No posting twice in a row without anyone else posting in between

- Keep to the topics in this interview or in previous comments

- Try to be nice

Bruce will, of course, also be told to keep to those rules. I will also be nagging him to actually do something about real contributions from TI to TEFL.net…

I must be the least likely blogger of all time, being neither technically savvy nor generally interested in online content- I’d never read a blog before I started this one, and I still reckon most of the best stuff is still in books. Anything from Zoltan available on the web? I thought not.

Once in a while though, I do stumble upon some good stuff. As that gives me even more stuff I want to read, I usually don’t find time to even mention it here, so here goes while I still feel a little recharged from my summer hols:

The Linguist Blogger

Some very thought provoking stuff, and perhaps a lesson to me that blogging less frequently produces greater quality… Two recent ones that particularly took my fancy:

Building Nations with the Cunning Use of Foreign Languages

Language Learning and Weight Lifting

Back in the world of TEFL, the other Dave is going through some highlights from his articles and he has chosen well, particularly:

In Search of a Word: Can Ambition Survive in TEFL?

When is it too late to get out of TEFL?

If like me you were stimulated by the ELT World articles but irritated by having to have a Google ID to comment, feel free to leave your comments here instead:

While I’m on the subject and have to make the most of Favourites on this PC (it’s staying in Japan when I go to Korea), here is a list of TEFL, linguistics and Japan related sites I most often end up at, in approximate order:

1. Dave’s ESL Cafe international job forums (the pointless bitching makes it more memorable somehow, maybe it’s the Dynasty of TEFL sites)

2. The TESall.com TEFL news ticker (including links to the forum discussions that are actually worthwhile)

3. The TEFL tradesman (as foul-mouthed and crusading as we’d all like to be)

4. The TEFL Blacklist (does exactly what it says in the title)

5. EL Gazette digital (a real TEFL newspaper. Click on the link on the main page to subscribe for free)

6. An Englishman in Osaka (just very funny, and so beats all the much more informative Japan blogs, of which there are many, in competing for my online time…)

7. Guardian TEFL (some real journalism would be nice- see EL Gazette for that- but a good way of keeping up with TEFL press releases anyway)

8. The Life of Mike (some odd changes of direction, but some thought provoking and entertaining posts)

9. Notes from the TEFL graveyard (hits the funny yet practical, cynical yet enjoying the life balance that I struggle with on my blog)

10. Teacher in Development (would probably be around number 2 if there were more posts)

11. Metatesol (pithy, to the point and almost inactive- this one would also be higher if this little bit of prompting results in more posts)

If I was a better person the list would probably be different, and Rave’s ESL Au Lait wouldn’t even be in the list let alone at the top and Insights into TEFL , Humanising Language Teaching  and Developing Teachers would be in there, but like my irrational desire to eat cheap gyudon, that is where I really end up. End of confession- how many Hail Mario’s for absolution?

Having been attacked by another person who has worked in a national university in Japan (what is wrong with these people- too much time on their hands or no one to talk to because the Japanese staff freeze them out??), here goes with another attempt to take this as an honest misunderstanding that I can clear up rather than just personality problems with them and/ or me: (more…)